ASSERTYVE.ORG

What is Fixed Pie Negotiation?

Fixed pie negotiation is a type of negotiation where one party believes that the resources or benefits being negotiated are fixed and limited. This mindset assumes that any gain made by one party will come at the expense of the other party. In other words, the pie is fixed, and if one person gets a bigger slice, someone else will get a smaller slice. This approach often leads to a competitive and adversarial negotiation style, where each party tries to maximize their gains at the expense of the other.

In a fixed pie negotiation, the focus is on distributing the existing resources rather than exploring ways to create more value. This approach can lead to a win-lose situation, where one party feels they have won, and the other party feels they have lost. For instance, in a salary negotiation, an employee may believe that the company has a fixed budget for salaries, and if they want a higher salary, they will have to convince the employer to take it away from someone else.

The Limitations of Fixed Pie Negotiation

Fixed pie negotiation has several limitations. Firstly, it assumes that the resources are fixed and limited, which is not always the case. In many situations, it is possible to create more value or find alternative solutions that benefit both parties. Secondly, this approach can lead to a lack of trust and communication between the parties involved. When each party is focused on maximizing their gains, they may not be willing to share information or collaborate to find a mutually beneficial solution.

Additionally, fixed pie negotiation can lead to a narrow focus on the immediate gains, rather than considering the long-term consequences. For example, in a business deal, a company may focus on getting the best price for their product, without considering the potential damage to their relationship with the supplier.

The Alternative: Expanding the Pie

Instead of focusing on distributing a fixed pie, negotiators can adopt an expanding pie approach. This approach involves exploring ways to create more value and finding solutions that benefit both parties. In an expanding pie negotiation, the focus is on collaboration and mutual gain, rather than competition and adversarial tactics.

To adopt an expanding pie approach, negotiators need to be open-minded and willing to listen to each other’s concerns and interests. They should focus on building trust and creating a positive relationship, rather than trying to outmaneuver each other. By working together, parties can often find creative solutions that satisfy both parties’ needs and create more value than initially thought possible.

Real-Life Examples of Expanding the Pie

One classic example of expanding the pie is the Camp David Accords, where Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin and Egyptian President Anwar El-Sadat negotiated a peace treaty. Instead of focusing on distributing the existing resources, they explored ways to create more value by establishing a peace agreement that benefited both countries.

Another example is the negotiation between the city of Boston and the Boston Red Sox baseball team over the construction of a new stadium. Instead of focusing on who would pay for the stadium, the parties explored ways to create more value by developing the surrounding area and creating new revenue streams.

Strategies for Expanding the Pie

To expand the pie, negotiators can use several strategies. Firstly, they should focus on building trust and establishing a positive relationship. This can be done by finding common interests and goals, and being transparent and open in their communication.

Secondly, negotiators should be willing to listen actively and ask questions to understand each other’s concerns and interests. This can help to identify potential areas of agreement and create opportunities for mutually beneficial solutions.

Thirdly, negotiators should be creative and open-minded in their approach. They should be willing to think outside the box and explore unconventional solutions that benefit both parties.

Finally, negotiators should be willing to make concessions and compromise. By being flexible and willing to give and take, parties can often find a solution that satisfies both parties’ needs.

Conclusion

Fixed pie negotiation is a common approach that assumes resources are fixed and limited. However, this approach can lead to a competitive and adversarial negotiation style, which can result in a win-lose situation. Instead, negotiators can adopt an expanding pie approach, which involves exploring ways to create more value and finding solutions that benefit both parties. By building trust, being open-minded, and willing to make concessions, parties can often find creative solutions that satisfy both parties’ needs and create more value than initially thought possible.

FAQ

What is fixed pie negotiation?

Fixed pie negotiation is a type of negotiation where one party believes that the resources or benefits being negotiated are fixed and limited.

What are the limitations of fixed pie negotiation?

The limitations of fixed pie negotiation include assuming resources are fixed and limited, leading to a lack of trust and communication, and a narrow focus on immediate gains.

What is expanding the pie?

Expanding the pie is an approach to negotiation that involves exploring ways to create more value and finding solutions that benefit both parties.

How can I adopt an expanding pie approach?

To adopt an expanding pie approach, focus on building trust, being open-minded, and willing to make concessions. Be creative and willing to think outside the box to find mutually beneficial solutions.